Purple Row: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





Views from the Top - Does Cash buy Championships?

Terry Frei would have us all dressed up with no place to go

After a pretty good article about not using altitude as an excuse, Terry Frei comes back with a pretty lame one this time around that rehashes the riches buy happiness story this girl has heard in one too many fairy-tales already. Let me just say that yes, capital investment is needed to be competitive, I'm not arguing that it's not. What I am saying is that baseball executives really need to rethink how they allocate that capital to achieve success. The model Frei suggests follows something similar to what the Diamondbacks seemingly do consistently in Arizona, or what several of my friends do consistently on shopping trips. Take some cash you don't have, buy some glamorous things you want, use glamorous looks to bring in cash or prominence. Yeah, that works in high school when you want to be homecoming queen, but it usually isn't the best model for competitive business success. Look at the Dodgers during the Rupert Murdoch years, a lot of cash thrown willy-nilly means little or nothing in the end if your front office hasn't done its homework. Look at our own team for that matter. This is where the Dodgers failed, this is where Dan O' Dowd and the Monforts have failed up to this point.

They have not spent the money or time to build the infrastructure of a championship team: namely, they haven't aggressively gone after scouts and bright front office talent -preferring nepotistic hires to talent searches (check out the front office and see how many of their hires are family members or friends of the Monforts), they have failed to build their international presence and allowed other teams to catch up in places like Taiwan where they had an early advantage, and they seem to be behind the curve in minor league player development and conditioning if the progress of our best prospects is any sort of measure (and it is).

The cure isn't a big name free agent, it doesn't have to be a new owner either. If Charlie Monfort seriously wants to be like the O'Malley's he has to think ahead of his time like the O'Malley's did in their pioneering Latin American scouting, or he has to be a shrewd evaluator (or hire these types) of people's baseball skills not only on the field in players and coaches, but in the front office, in player development (I like Bill Geivett and Bill Schmidt, honestly, but I wonder if we're not surrounding them with the right underlings) in all aspects of the organization and be willing to let go when the people he has aren't meeting the bar.

Listen, if this is just a fashion show, go ahead and buy the pretty dress, but if you're serious about a complete makeover, I want to see the personal trainer, the salon team, the dietician and the dressmaker before I'm willing to buy into your empty resolutions.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Don't give up on the youth movement
One bad season, and everybody is ready to give up on the youth movement that the Rockies have going and say "let's be like the Diamondbacks."

The Diamondbacks tried playing with the talent they had developed last season and they flopped to the tune of a 51-111 record.  Then the Diamondbacks went out and signed some big-name free agents to go with their homegrown players, and they're contenders again.  This is basically what the Diamondbacks did before they won the World Series.

That doesn't mean the Rockies should abandon growing their own talent.  The Rox can do this; but one thing we can learn from the Twins (who do the same thing) is that you need patience.

by Rox Fan in TN on May 24, 2005 1:32 PM MDT   0 recs

Exactly, Patience..,
But the Twins have more than patience, they have a highly effective foreign scouting and development staff, the right player development people on their farm teams rather than just local ex-pros who might not have the best teaching skills, and a well run system in place up top and throughout to bring those prospects along smoothly. This route is generally much cheaper than the free agent route (except in the case of Miguel Cabrera) and can be effective, but my problem with the Rockies is that at the very top they seem to have the right people, but then as you go down the system you have holes that our prospects are getting caught in. Witness Lo's recent strugggles in Asheville, or the rash of hamstring pulls that have hurt the development of our two best prospects among others. I worry about the system when I see so many cracks developing. Our draft remains very solid, we seem to have a good leg up in the Dominican, but other areas aren't functioning the way they should on a perpetual contender.

by Rox Girl on May 24, 2005 2:07 PM MDT to parent up   0 recs

Part of the problem...
Part of the problem is that prospects are just that: prospects.  Plenty of pitching prospects have been derailed by injuries in the past.

One thing that needs to be noted is that organizations such as the Twins have depth in prospects.  I posted a diary about the "youth movement" and how it bodes for the future.  Part of the point is that if guys like Nelson don't pan out, the Rockies really don't have a lot of other options.

Also worth noting is that of Stewart, Lo, and Nelson, only Stewart has even reached age 20.  There's plenty of time for them.

by Rox Fan in TN on May 24, 2005 2:28 PM MDT to parent up   0 recs

Comment from Rox Head via e-mail
You know, I'm not surprised that Frei would give up on the current course the Rockies are on so fast. It doesn't fit their model of "Produce now or we'll get the whole bunch of you run out of town because we have the ear of the public and we know better than you do."

The scary thing is, is that the main steam media actually DOES have the ear of the powers that be and CAN influence the decision making quite a bit. I bet if the owners would just read some of the stuff you have been writing here, then they'd know that they are on the right course, that this is actually something they HAVEN'T tried before, and to give the rebuilding effort a few years and a few dollars lost because Frei is totally wrong ... once this team starts winning, then the fans WILL come back immediately.

roxhead



e-mail posted

by Rox Girl on May 25, 2005 7:15 AM MDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Colorado Rockies.

Established 28 April 2005.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

212013248044830ea9b5ccb_small
Rockies Trade Juan Castro
Small
Why This Year Isn't As Bad As We Think
Small
Chacin and Roe
Apt_visit_2_small
All Star Game Wallpaper - It Actually Looks Good!
Fsn_2_small
Rockies All Access for Thurs., July 17 at 6:00 p.m. on FSN
Du_animated2_small
Could the Rockies get Bedard?
Godzill-as_small
First Coors Field Trip - Recap
Small
Injuries
748_small
Aaron Cook gets the Kiss of Death
S6301199_small
Where are they going to go?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Me_small Russ

Li_l_rox_girl_small Rox Girl

Bench Coaches

Nixie2_small malakian

Small David OhNo

ad

Site Meter