clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Which Rockies should make the All-Star team?

Nolan Arenado will definitely be there, but who else?

The 90th Major League Baseball All-Star Game is right around the corner. If you haven’t already, make sure you’ve cleared your schedule for Tuesday, July 9, to watch this game, which has no bearing on the standings or postseason whatsoever.

Because I like making lists, I have put myself in the shoes of Alex Cora and Dave Roberts and compiled my 34-man rosters for each league. Going through this process has shown me that it can be extremely difficult to find a spot for a member of every team—the Blue Jays, Giants, Mariners, Marlins, Orioles and Pirates gave me issues. Perhaps there should either be an expansion of the rosters or an elimination of the rule that every team must be represented.

Just to keep things organized, I looked at squads from the previous few seasons and did my best to replicate how rosters were calibrated. I have three catchers for each team, eight starting pitchers (Yonny Chirinos for the Rays is a bit of an outlier as he’s been used as an opener, reliever and full-fledged starter at times), four relief pitchers and at least six outfield spots. Beyond that, I made sure there were at least two of each infield position.

The American League


SP: Chris Sale, Boston Red Sox

C: Robinson Chirinos, Houston Astros

1B: Carlos Santana, Cleveland Indians

2B: DJ LeMahieu, New York Yankees

SS: Jorge Polanco, Minnesota Twins

3B: Alex Bregman, Houston Astros

OF: Mookie Betts, Boston Red Sox

OF: Byron Buxton, Minnesota Twins

OF: Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels

DH: J.D. Martinez, Boston Red Sox


C: Roberto Pérez, Cleveland Indians

C: Christian Vázquez, Boston Red Sox

1B: Hunter Dozier, Kansas City Royals

1B: Daniel Vogelbach, Seattle Mariners

2B: Gleyber Torres, New York Yankees

3B: Matt Chapman, Oakland Athletics

3B: Rafael Devers, Boston Red Sox

SS: Xander Bogaerts, Boston Red Sox

SS: Marcus Semien, Oakland Athletics

SS: Freddy Galvis, Toronto Blue Jays

OF: Joey Gallo, Texas Rangers

OF: Max Kepler, Minnesota Twins

OF: George Springer, Houston Astros

Pitching Staff

Matt Barnes, Boston Red Sox

Cam Bedrosian, Los Angeles Angels

Matthew Boyd, Detroit Tigers

Yonny Chirinos, Tampa Bay Rays

Gerrit Cole, Houston Astros

Lucas Giolito, Chicago White Sox

John Means, Baltimore Orioles

Mike Minor, Texas Rangers

Charlie Morton, Tampa Bay Rays

Justin Verlander, Houston Astros

Brandon Workman, Boston Red Sox


Look at that. LeMahieu has left Coors Field and he’s still a starter on the All-Star team.

Sale over Verlander for starting pitcher might turn some heads here. Sale’s win-loss record may not look as pretty as Verlander’s, but Sale has an even better strikeout rate and Verlander has struggled with the home run ball (1.67 HR/9), which is a bit concerning, even in what may be the juiced ball era.

The National League


SP: Stephen Strasburg, Washington Nationals

C: Yasmani Grandal, Milwaukee Brewers

1B: Anthony Rizzo, Chicago Cubs

2B: Ketel Marte, Arizona Diamondbacks

SS: Trevor Story, Colorado Rockies

3B: Nolan Arenado, Colorado Rockies

OF: Ronald Acuña Jr., Atlanta Braves

OF: Cody Bellinger, Los Angeles Dodgers

OF: Christian Yelich, Milwaukee Brewers

DH: Anthony Rendon, Washington Nationals


C: Austin Hedges, San Diego Padres

C: J.T. Realmuto, Philadelphia Phillies

1B: Max Muncy, Los Angeles Dodgers

2B: Kolten Wong, St Louis Cardinals

SS: Javier Báez, Chicago Cubs

SS: Paul DeJong, St Louis Cardinals

SS: Dansby Swanson, Atlanta Braves

3B: Kris Bryant, Chicago Cubs

3B: Evan Longoria, San Francisco Giants

3B: Justin Turner, Los Angeles Dodgers

OF: Michael Conforto, New York Mets

OF: Marcell Ozuna, St Louis Cardinals

OF: Hunter Renfroe, San Diego Padres

Pitching Staff

Luis Castillo, Cincinnati Reds

Jacob deGrom, New York Mets

John Gant, St Louis Cardinals

Josh Hader, Milwaukee Brewers

Luke Jackson, Atlanta Braves

Pablo López, Miami Marlins

Jordan Lyles, Pittsburgh Pirates

German Márquez, Colorado Rockies

Hyun-Jin Ryu, Los Angeles Dodgers

Max Scherzer, Washington Nationals

Kirby Yates, San Diego Padres


Báez has absolutely been running away with the voting for starting shortstop, but here’s the thing—Story should start because he’s having a better year. Story leads Báez in all three versions of WAR, and has come up with better marks in batting, fielding and baserunning. And yet, Story ranks fourth in the voting for shortstop in the NL, after Báez, Swanson and Corey Seager.

There is a new caveat to All-Star voting this year. Primary voting will end at 10 AM MT on Friday, June 21. The top three vote-getters at each position will advance to a special starter’s election for 28 hours beginning at 10:00 a.m. MT on Wednesday, June 26. Right now, Story would not be in that election (though he has pulled within 50,000 votes of Seager). If there’s anything you take away from this post, I hope it’s that I implore you to get out and vote for Trevor Story.

As for other Rockies, Arenado’s inclusion probably goes without saying. He’s rightly running away with the third base voting at this time.

I have included German Márquez as a member of the NL pitching staff. Despite recent struggles that have inflated his ERA, Márquez is still sporting a pristine 2.49 DRA (nearly 50 percent better than league average). He deserves to be there.

Some potential snubs you may be wondering about are Charlie Blackmon, David Dahl, Scott Oberg and Tony Wolters.

I just barely gave the third outfield spot to Renfroe over Blackmon. Heck, if Blackmon has another week similar to the one he just had, I’ll have Blackmon take over. Dahl has been very good as well, but there are just too many good players in the game. The same can be said for Oberg. There’s a lot of good relievers out there.

I’m sure you’re looking for an explanation about the inclusion of Hedges, even though Tony 3 Bags is hitting over 100 points higher than him. I simply have to say that Hedges is in another category among defensive catchers in the game and for the third backstop on the team, that gets my vote. Also—Hedges’ walk-up song is “Careless Whisper.” How can you not vote for that?

Don’t get caught up in your anger over that though. Channel your ire into voting for Trevor Story.

Finally, there’s no voting for a designated hitter in the NL, but there’s always a starting DH anyway, so I’m not sure why fans can’t vote for them. I gave that spot to Rendon as the best player I didn’t have starting.

Feel free to drop your thoughts on which Rockies should be in the All-Star Game in the comments. Or drop your entire roster if you feel like committing to that undertaking.

You can cast your All-Star votes for Trevor Story here.